Porsche 986 Boxster buyer’s guide
The 986 generation is the first Porsche Boxster, and the car that pulled Porsche out of its early nineties sales slump and arguably saved the brand. It's mid-engined, rear-wheel drive, and relatively cheap to acquire now. Designed by Grant Larson, with a nose it shares with Pinky Lai's 996, the Boxster is a parts bin special that borrows elements from its older brother, but in many ways, is arguably the superior car — especially when it comes to dollars per smile.
What makes the 986 Boxster interesting
It's the car that saved Porsche. In 1992 the company sold about 15,000 cars worldwide. The 928 and 968 weren't selling, and the 911 was never a high volume car. Porsche sent its managers to learn from Toyota, hired a consultancy of former Toyota staff, and at the end of 1996 reported its first profit in four years.
The other half of the plan was sharing parts. Porsche had always built each model on its own. The Boxster and the next 911, the 996, were developed side by side and shared the new water-cooled flat-six, the bonnet, the front wings, the headlights and much of the interior. They share the doors too. Some of the complaints about Porsches of this era are that they don't feel "premium" in a way other cars in this segment do due to plastic-y interiors and trendy rounded buttons.
Then there are the headlights. Every road-going Porsche before it had round or oval lamps, with the indicators down in the bumper. The Boxster concept put the beams and the indicators in one teardrop unit, and owners christened it the "fried egg". The folks on the internet have bemoaned these to death, but if you can look past them, you'll see a car that is truly magic.
The trouble was that the 996 got the same lamps. Buyers paying 911 money found their car looked like the cheaper one, and the 911 crowd let Porsche hear about it. For 2002 the 911 got sharper lamps of its own, borrowed from the Turbo. The 986's lights were tweaked in the same year and lost some of their yolk.
The layout is the magic formula here. The engine sits behind the seats and ahead of the rear axle, so the car changes direction quickly and still has room for a trunk at each end. This makes it surprisingly forgiving to drive, and suspiciously practical for a two-seat roadster. It was the only mid-engined flat-six car on the market when it came out, and as it stands today, the early car is a used performance car bargain.
986 Boxster odds and ends
You can’t see the engine.
Open the rear lid and you find a trunk. Open the front and you find another one. The dipsticks and fluid fillers live in the rear trunk, so you can top up the engine without ever seeing it. Getting to the engine from above means parking the top halfway, lifting out the storage box behind the seats and the trim panel under it, then the engine cover. Most service work is done from underneath.
It has two trunks.
One in the nose and one behind the engine, so there's useful luggage space front and rear.
Early cars have no glovebox.
Pre-facelift cars make do with deep cubbies in each door. The 2003 facelift added a glovebox in the dash.
Early tops have a plastic rear window.
Cars through the 2002 model year have a large, flexible plastic window. For 2003 Porsche revised the top and fitted a heated glass window. The glass is smaller, and owners point out that the plastic one is easier to see out of.
The windows drop when you open the door.
Pull either handle and the glass lowers a little, then rises again when the door shuts. Seven microswitches in each door run the trick, and when one sticks the window either won't drop or goes straight back up.
The fried eggs can fry themselves.
A plastic inner lens sits right in front of the low-beam bulb, and over years of use it browns and can burn through. It's worst on cars that run their low beams all day. New halogen units have listed at more than $2,000 each, and owners report that cleaning can't fix a yellowed inner lens.
The engine computer remembers every over-rev.
The DME logs how many times the engine went past its limit, in two ranges, and the engine hours at the last event. A shop can print it. More on reading it below.
The car’s brain sits under a seat.
The alarm control unit, which also controls the ignition, lives under a seat. Blocked top drains send water into the footwell, and a soaked unit is an expensive repair. Wet carpet behind the seats is the warning.
How the 986 Boxster fails
There are five main problems to look out for when in the market for a used Porsche 986 Boxster. A full history from a Porsche dealer or a recognised specialist is worth more than low miles and a car that's been driven hard and well loved beats a garage queen.
Will the IMS bearing take out a 986’s engine?
It can. Most never fail, but when one does it usually wrecks the engine, so it's the first thing to ask a seller about: has it been retrofitted, and is there an invoice? LN Engineering puts a little badge by the door. The failure rate is low, but if it goes, the car is probably toast or a good candidate for a bigger engine swap.
The intermediate shaft runs the camshafts off the crankshaft. Its back end rides on a sealed ball bearing that pressurised oil can't reach, because the crankcase has no oil passage there. If the bearing wears, the shaft can wander, the cam timing goes, and the valves can meet the pistons. Debris from the failure goes through the whole engine, which is why a failure usually means a rebuild or a replacement engine. The Porsche Club of America filmed a 26-minute explainer on how it works and how it changed over the years.
Which bearing a car has depends on when its engine was built. Original 1997 to 1999 engines have a dual-row bearing. Engines from 2000 and 2001 can have either the dual-row or a smaller single-row bearing. From 2002 every 986 engine has the single-row one. LN Engineering lists the engine serial numbers where the change happened: 2.7 litre engines from M 651 12852 and 3.2 litre engines from M 671 11238 should have the single-row bearing. An engine with X or AT in its serial number is a factory replacement and carries whatever bearing Porsche was fitting when it was built. The only sure test is to look at the bearing flange once the gearbox is off.
How much the early bearing helps is argued over. LN Engineering, which makes retrofit kits, cites the class action for an 8 percent failure rate on the single-row bearing against less than 1 percent on the dual-row. Hartech, a UK engine rebuilder, says the two bearings had similar load ratings and similar failure rates. Long-time owners warn that the forum statistics come largely from people selling fixes. One shop that has worked on Porsches for 40 years has seen only six or seven failures since 1998, and says they cluster in cars that sit, not cars that get driven hard.
There's often no warning. When there is one, it's metal: sparkly magnetic debris on the drain plug or in the oil filter means stop driving and plan the job. Used oil analysis can't see it, because the debris is larger than what a standard oil analysis measures. A leak at the back of the engine can also be the IMS cover seal or a broken centre bolt, which points at a failing bearing.
The fix is well known. A specialist replaces the original with an upgraded bearing, usually while the gearbox is out for a clutch, so the labour is shared. LN puts the job at 10 to 14 hours of labour, and suggests dropping the sump and bore scoping the cylinders first. One specialist charges $3,300 or $4,300 for the retrofit, depending on the kit. A rebuilt engine costs $25,000 to $35,000.
There was also a class action. Eisen v. Porsche Cars North America settled in 2013 and covered Boxsters and 911s from the 2001 to 2005 model years. It paid a share of repair costs after a failure, scaled by mileage, for up to ten years from the car going into service or 130,000 miles. Nothing was paid for replacing a bearing before it failed. Every covered car is now past ten years, so the settlement pays nothing today. Its paperwork can still turn up in a car's folder, and it tells you the engine has already had an IMS failure.
Is a rear main seal leak a big deal on a 986?
Usually not by itself. One specialist says that as long as oil isn't dripping on the floor, it can usually wait until the car needs a clutch. Make sure the leak really is the seal. RMS is usually one of those things you can wait for and do "while you're in there".
The rear main seal is where the crankshaft leaves the engine. On the 986 it can leak into the bell housing, and oil left there can spoil the clutch and flywheel. Many owners only notice when oil reaches the ground. Porsche revised the seal several times, and one theory is that some seal bores were cast slightly oval. Owners report it more on manual cars than on Tiptronics, and some cars have had it done more than once.
The cost is in the access, because the gearbox and clutch have to come out. A good shop presses the new seal in with the Porsche tool rather than tapping it in. Since the IMS bearing sits behind the same gearbox, shops commonly do the clutch, rear main seal and IMS together. If the seller has an invoice for one, look for the others on the same page.
One caution. Oil at the back of the engine isn't always the seal. A failing IMS bearing can make its cover seal leak, and it gets mistaken for a rear main seal.
Do 986 Boxster engines crack cylinders or score their bores?
Rarely. Cracked liners and scored bores are mostly a story about the bigger engines that came after. It's still worth having the bores scoped before you buy.
Hartech, which rebuilds these engines, says the 2.5, 2.7 and 3.2 litre Boxster engines it opened for IMS work showed no cracked bores and no D-chunking, where a D-shaped piece breaks off the bottom of a liner. Its explanation is wall thickness. The Boxster engines have thicker cylinder walls than the 3.4 that followed, and the trouble grew as bores got bigger and walls got thinner. One Porsche shop says bore scoring is rare in 986-era cars compared with later generations.
Owners do report D-chunks on 986s, more often in cold months and least often on the 3.2, and blame driving off before the engine is fully warm. The earliest engines had their own problems. Some early 1997 blocks were porous, and some mid-1998 to early-1999 engines slipped a cylinder sleeve. Porsche replaced the engines that failed, often in their first 10,000 miles, and a dealer can tell from the VIN whether a car's engine was replaced. A replacement engine in the history isn't a reason to walk away.
If you see oil smoke, the cheaper suspect comes first. A failing air-oil separator lets oil into the intake, and the classic sign is a big cloud on start-up or after hard cornering.
Why do 986 radiators fail?
They sit behind the ducts in the front corners and catch leaves. As the leaves mulch down they rot the radiators, which can last as little as six years.
Take the front bumper off a 986 that has never been cleaned and you'll find damp leaves and grit packed in each corner. One owner pulling the bumper for the first time found a piece of woodchip in there, and fitted mesh behind the grilles afterwards. Owners who do the job use a vacuum with a soft brush, and say most of the debris hides between the air conditioning condenser and the radiator. The Boxster S got an additional radiator.
The other weak point is the plastic coolant expansion tank. It lives in the rear trunk under the carpet, and its bottom cracks with age. A shop that found one on a car back from storage described coolant everywhere under the carpet. Long-time owners list the tank among the common replacements worth asking a seller about.
Which 986 Boxsters have a plastic rear window?
Cars through the 2002 model year. For 2003 Porsche revised the top and fitted a heated glass rear window. The later top and frame can be fitted to earlier cars, so check the car rather than the year.
The plastic window clouds and goes brittle as it dries out, and a dry window folded in the cold can crack. Owners who keep theirs clear treat both sides with a plastic polish twice a year.
The top's drive cables are the other known fault, especially on 1997 to 1999 cars. Heat stretches the outer sleeve of each cable until it pushes the inner cable out of the motor. The two sides stretch at different rates, so one side of the top keeps working and the other lags or stops. Owners who have been through it say most expensive top repairs come from holding the button down after one side has stopped. Cables also rot with age, and replacing a snapped one is a common forum question.
Water is the third. The top drains into trays that empty just ahead of the rear wheels. When a drain blocks or a tray tears, water ends up behind and under the seats, where the alarm control unit lives. And the window trick that lets the doors clear the top relies on microswitches in each door that wear out. A UK specialist notes that Boxsters and 996s need their electric window parts replaced quite often.
What to check before you buy a 986 Boxster
Do these roughly in this order. Have a Porsche specialist do a pre purchase inspection, not a generic shop.
Start it cold.
Ask the seller not to warm it up. Watch the tailpipes. A big cloud of oil smoke on start-up points at the air-oil separator. Ask how the car was warmed up in the past. A car run hard from cold is one to walk away from.
Cycle the top a few times.
It should go up and down without one side lagging. If one side stops, let go of the button. Look at the rear window while it folds.
Open every door.
Pull the inside and outside handles in turn. The window should drop and rise again when the door shuts.
Feel the carpet behind the seats.
Damp carpet usually means blocked top drains.
Lift the rear trunk carpet.
Look at the coolant tank and the floor around it for cracks and coolant.
Get the over-rev report and the cam deviation.
A shop with the Porsche tester can print the DME's over-rev log. The same scan shows camshaft deviation, which tells you how worn the timing chain guides are.
Bore scope it, and look at the oil filter.
Ask for the cylinders to be scoped and the photos sent to you. If an oil change is due, cut the filter open and look for metal.
How do you read a 986 over-rev report?
Look at range 2 first. On a 986, range 1 counts ignitions between 7,200 and 7,900 rpm, where Porsche says engine damage is possible. Range 2 counts ignitions above 7,900 rpm, where damage is probable.
The report also shows the engine hours at the last over-rev. Porsche tells its dealers that if engine damage turns up within about 50 operating hours of an over-rev, the over-rev probably caused it. Because events are logged in time intervals, a car can show range 2 counts with no range 1 counts. Later Boxsters log six ranges, so a chart from a 987 forum thread won't match a 986 report.
Porsche names changing into the wrong gear on a manual car as a typical cause. It asks dealers to call its technical hotline before granting a used-car warranty on any car with range 2 entries.
Records to ask a 986 Boxster seller for
On this car the folder is worth as much as the drive. Maintenance has a time limit as well as a mileage one, because rubber dries out and fluids break down in cars that sit. A seller who has these will be glad you asked.
| Record | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| IMS retrofit invoice | The biggest risk on the car, settled on one page. Retrofit bearings have their own service interval, so the date matters too. |
| Engine serial number, or an engine replacement | Tells you which IMS bearing it should have, and whether the engine is a factory replacement. |
| Clutch and rear main seal | Usually done together, and often with the IMS. |
| DME over-rev report | How it was driven, in two numbers. |
| Inspection report with bore scope photos | The cylinders, seen. |
| Air-oil separator and chain guides | The other preventive jobs specialists recommend on these engines. |
| Radiators, condensers and expansion tank | Radiators can last as little as six years, so a recent invoice counts. |
| Top replacement | Tells you which rear window it has and how old the top is. |
| Oil changes, with dates and mileage | The pattern matters more than any one stamp. Specialists suggest every 5,000 miles or six months for street cars. |
The short version
| What fails | What you'd notice | What to check | Record that settles it | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IMS bearing | Often nothing before it goes. Sometimes glittery metal in the oil filter. | The filter and drain plug at an oil change, and which bearing the engine has. | An invoice for an IMS retrofit, with its date. | Read → |
| Rear main seal | Oil where the engine meets the gearbox, and drips under the middle of the car. | A look underneath on a lift. A leak here can also be the IMS cover. | The seal replaced while the gearbox was out, usually with the clutch. | Read → |
| Cylinders | Rare on the 986. Oil smoke on start-up is more often the air-oil separator. | A bore scope as part of the inspection. | The inspection report with the scope photos, or an engine replacement on record. | Read → |
| Cooling | Leaves in the front grilles, and coolant under the rear trunk carpet. | The radiators behind the front bumper ducts. | Radiators cleaned or replaced, and the expansion tank replaced. | Read → |
| Top and windows | A cloudy plastic rear window, one side of the top lagging, a window that won't drop. | Cycle the top and open each door. | A top, cable or window switch invoice. | Read → |